Things we know from those White Rose expense reports

If nothing else, those Reich accountants kept solid records. We’ve already seen that the Gestapo crime lab was unhappy with BMW’s shoddy inventory controls. The accounting files for the three White Rose trials extensively document behind-the-scenes operations, as well as provide data points that nail down critical events related to the investigation and trials.
Highlights of these expense reports and how they affect the accuracy of the story:
- Although Reich Deputy Prosecutor Bischoff left for Munich on 2/20, arriving that evening, and although he officially “prepared the indictment”, nothing happened that day. No indictment, no court-appointed defense counsel.
- On February 21, Bischoff appointed August Klein as defense counsel for the Scholl siblings and Ferdinand Seidl II for Christoph Probst. This appointment was unofficial, and they would not be sworn in until the morning of the trial. Defense counsel was advised the indictment would be published late afternoon, and they would have until 2/22 at 8 am to enter a plea. Trial scheduled for 2/22 at 10 am.
- Reich Prosecutor Weyersberg joined his deputy in Munich on 2/21. Weyersberg held a “pre-trial conference for criminal proceedings,” likely with Bischoff. Indictment finally published and “served” on defense counsel.
- August Klein held a one-hour pre-trial conference with Hans and Sophie Scholl, apparently jointly. He did not state whether that conference was held the evening of 2/21 or the morning of 2/22. Ferdinand Seidl’s invoice for services rendered was not submitted, so we do not know if he met with Christoph Probst.
- The evening of 2/21, Judge Roland Freisler, Dr. Stier (Director of the Regional Court), and Bailiff Kosemund left Berlin for Munich. Freisler and Stier traveled on the same train, with sleeping accommodations, arriving in Munich at 9:30 am on 2/22. Kosemund’s 3rd class ticket got him into Munich at 7:05 am.
- Early on 2/22, Christoph Probst penned an impassioned plea for leniency. The plea entered on his behalf by Seidl and the pleas on behalf of the Scholls were not contained in the prosecutor’s ZC13267 files.
- Time stamps that make a difference:
- Bailiff Kosemund noted that court was in session at 10 am. He was paid on the basis of this claim. [It’s also noted by Leo Samberger, the law student who took the most detailed notes of this trial, that Kosemund asked witnesses to leave the courtroom at that time.]
- Unknown when the two prosecutors arrived. Weyersberg and Bischoff merely stated that they were present for the trial and were paid their requisite per diem for participation.
- Freisler and Stier both recorded time the trial started as 11 am. This corresponds with Samberger’s account, but contradicts almost everyone else’s. According to non-accounting records, after a short recess for a break around noon, Freisler returned shortly thereafter and improvised his verdict.
- Kosemund stated that his “business purpose for trip” ended at 12:40 pm. He was paid for his work as bailiff (sergeant-at-arms) only through 12:40. The trial transcript supports Kosemund’s record, as the court clerk noted the trial ended at 12:45 pm.
- Freisler and Stier stated that the business purpose for trip ended at 2 pm. This tracks with non-accounting records, as after the improvised verdict, the two men drafted the official verdict, as well as orders regarding disposition of the evidence. Freisler handwrote an order stating that the duplicating machine and “the typewriter” [there were two] were to be confiscated for use by the Reich.
- The verdict noted that the Scholl and Probst families were to bear all costs related to the trial.
- Weyersberg’s “business purpose” ended at 5:30 pm. He stayed for the executions, noting on his expense report, “supervision of the execution of the death penalty.” Bischoff left this blank.
- Kosemund took the two machines back to Berlin and subsequently charged the Reich “cartage” for so doing.
- Freisler, Stier, and Kosemund left for Berlin the evening of 2/22.
- Weyersberg and Bischoff left for Berlin the morning of 2/23.
- Also on 2/23, Breithaupt/SS-Gruppenführer and Major General of the Waffen-SS in Munich prepared the official copies of the indictment and verdicts and circulated to all parties. He then issued an invoice to the Reich for the fees.
If you have seen either the Verhoeven or the Breinersdorfer movies, you will recognize that much of what they portrayed was created out of thin air for dramatic effect. Or was based on narratives by Jürgen Wittenstein, Inge Scholl, her father Robert Scholl, and others who used their story to reinvent themselves postwar.
I keep stressing how important it is to treat historical data as exactly that: Data. No, not everything will fall exactly into place. But if all data is taken into account and not cherry-picked, the true story takes shape and is more powerful than the fiction.
These three people, plus the additional 25 or so in the inner circle of White Rose friends [not six as non-serious historians would have you believe], plus another 150 who helped the close friends in one way or another? They deserve the most serious treatment of their courage possible.
They deserve our undying respect.
THE ATTORNEYS WHO REPRESENTED THE DEFENDANTS
August Klein: Court-appointed counsel for Hans and Sophie Scholl. Unofficial appointment made on 2/21, with official “swearing-in” as defense counsel on the morning of 2/22. Klein was advised that the indictment would be completed that afternoon, and he would have until the morning of 2/22 to enter a plea. Trial set for 10 am on 2/22.
On 2/23/43, Klein invoiced the Volksgericht (People’s Court) for one hour pre-trial conference with both Hans and Sophie Scholl (together?), and two hours in court. He added in VAT plus miscellaneous expenditures for postage and telephone expenses, for a total of RM 184.00 [$1472.00].
Ferdinand Seidl II: Court-appointed counsel for Christoph Probst. Appointment made on 2/21, with official “swearing-in” as defense counsel on the morning of 2/22. Seidl was advised that the indictment would be completed that afternoon, and he would have until the morning of 2/22 to enter a plea. Trial set for 10 am on 2/22.
Noteworthy that Seidl’s invoice was not included in the prosecutor’s expense file [ZC13267 Vol. 14]. Additionally, Christoph Probst was apparently dissatisfied with his attorney’s defense, because he penned a letter to the court early on the morning of 2/22. It was disregarded.
TRIAL COSTS
Roland Freisler, Presiding Judge:
- 2/20/43 travel advance RM 50 [$400.00].
- From Freisler’s expense report filed on 2/24/43. Note that Director Stier signed Freisler’s expense report on his behalf.
- 2/21 at 8:40 pm, train left Berlin. Traveled 1st class sleeper car via Nürnberg. No charge to the Reich, “since Minister of the Reich.”
- 2/22 at 9:30 am, arrived in Munich.
- 2/22 at 11 am, court in session.
- 2/22 at 2 pm, business purpose of trip ended. He received per diem of RM 26.50 [$212.00].
- 2/22 at 10 pm, train left for Berlin. Traveled 2nd class sleeper car via Nürnberg.
- 2/23 at 9:12 am, arrived in Berlin.
- 2/25/43, accounting paid balance owed of RM 17.50 [$140.00].
- 4/1/43 accounting noted RM 67.50 [$540.00] for total travel costs.
Dr. Stier, Director of the Regional Court:
- 2/20/43 travel advance RM 120 [$960.00].
- From Stier’s expense report filed on 2/24/43. Note that Stier did not sign his expense report.
- 2/21 at 8:40 pm, train left Berlin. Traveled 2nd class sleeper car via Nürnberg. No charge to the Reich, “since Minister of the Reich.”
- 2/22 at 9:30 am, arrived in Munich.
- 2/22 at 11 am, court in session.
- 2/22 at 2 pm, business purpose of trip ended. He received per diem of RM 25.00 [$200.00].
- 2/22 at 9:24 pm, train left for Berlin. Traveled 2nd class, no sleeper car via Regensburg.
- 2/23 at 9:27, arrived in Berlin.
- 2/25/43, accounting paid balance owed of RM 6.30 [$50.40].
- 4/1/43 accounting noted RM 126.30 [$1010.40] for travel costs.
Reich Prosecutor Weyersberg:
- 2/20/43 not on list for travel advance.
- 2/20/43 after the fact, travel advance initially noted as RM 160 [$1280.00], marked out and increased to RM 180 [$1440.00].
- From Weyersberg’s expense report filed on 2/24/43.
- 2/20 at 8 pm, train left Berlin. Traveled 1st class via Regensburg.
- 2/21 at 8:43 am, arrived in Munich.
- 2/21, “pre-trial conference for criminal proceedings against Scholl et al for high treason.”
- 2/22, “session for the abovementioned matter and supervision of the execution of the death penalty.” No time given.
- 2/22 at 5:30 pm, business purpose of trip ended. He received per diem of RM 30 [$240.00]. Note that Weyersberg stayed for the executions, reason for later end time.
- 2/23 at 7 am, train left for Berlin. Traveled 2nd class, no sleeper car via Regensburg.
- 2/23 at 6:30 pm, arrived in Berlin.
- 2/26/43, accounting paid balance owed of RM 9.00 [$72.00].
- 4/1/43 accounting noted RM 171.00 [$1368.00] for travel costs.
Reich Deputy Prosecutor Bischoff:
- 2/20/43 added after the fact in handwriting as RM 0.
- From Bischoff’s expense report filed on 2/24/43.
- 2/20 at 8 pm, train left Berlin. Traveled 2nd class via Halle.
- 2/20 at 6:10 pm, arrived in Munich.
- 2/20, “evening, preparation of indictment.”
- 2/21, publishing of indictment, service of legal process, [illegible] interrogation.
- 2/21 at 9:20 pm, left for Regensburg. 2nd class. Arrived 11:31 pm.
- 2/22 at 6:31 am, left for Munich, arrived 8:20 am. Bischoff charged the Reich RM 6 [$72.00] for sleeper car for this trip and RM 5.10 [$40.80] for hotel.
- 2/22, trial and [illegible]. No time given.
- Time that business purpose of trip ended was left blank. He received per diem of RM 24 [$192.00].
- 2/23 at 7 am, train left for Berlin. Traveled 2nd class via Leipzig.
- 2/23 at 6:30 pm, arrived in Berlin.
- 2/25/43, accounting paid balance owed of RM 183.30 [$1466.40].
- 4/1/43 accounting noted RM 183.30 [$1466.40] for travel costs.
Bailiff Kosemund:
- 2/20/43 travel advance RM 80 [$640.00].
- From Kosemund’s expense report filed on 2/23/43.
- 2/21 at 8:02 pm, train left Berlin. Traveled 3rd class, no stops.
- 2/22 at 7:05 am, arrived in Munich.
- 2/22, Kosemund spent RM 2.10 [$16.80] (RM 0.75 each way + RM 0.60 for a porter in Berlin) on public transportation to the Justizpalast [Palace of Justice].
- 2/22 at 10 am, court was in session.
- 2/22 at 12:40 pm, court adjourned and business purpose of trip ended.
- 2/22 at 5:30 pm, business purpose of trip ended. He received per diem of RM 9 [$$72.00].
- 2/22 at 9:24 pm, train left for Berlin. Traveled 3rd class, no stops.
- 2/23 at 9:12 am, arrived in Berlin.
- 2/23/43, accounting paid balance owed of RM 3.25 [$26.00].
- 4/20/43, Kosemund charged the People’s Court RM 4.37 [$34.96] for “cartage for crates and office equipment, items from Munich.”
- 4/1/43 accounting noted RM 76.75 [$614.00] for travel costs.
Other:
- Very faint, but appears to be GeStaPo invoiced People’s Court RM 24.00 [$192.00] for expenses from 2/23-2/25/43 related to Scholl and Probst. From following documents, appears to have been charges from Breithaupt/SS-Gruppenführer and Major General of the Waffen-SS for certified copies of the indictment and verdict.
Note: The bottom photograph gives you an idea of the short distances involved in the above expense reports. It's a fairly short distance from the Hauptbahnhof (main train station) to the Justizpalast (courthouse).
Demand facts, not truthiness.
Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.
If you enjoyed this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!
Excerpted from White Rose History, Volume II. See below for copyright information. Please contact us for permission to quote. If you use this information in a Senior Honors paper, a thesis, or a dissertation, a book, a magazine article, on your Web site, PLEASE CITE PROPERLY! I go after plagiarists.
Additionally, if you wish to understand the above data IN CONTEXT, please order White Rose History, Volume II. If you want to read the primary source documents in English translation, see our primary sources.
Image credits: Top photograph--Justizpalast [Palace of Justice], 1930. Location of First White Rose trial on 2/22/1943. Public domain. Bottom photograph--L to R, Main train station, Grand Hotel Bellevue (middle), Justizpalast (right). Public domain.
The above information is fully footnoted in our White Rose histories. Please purchase them for access to that material! To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.
No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.
