The importance of the crime lab

The work of the crime lab (to use a more modern term for that particular investigative function in 1943) started long before the arrests of February 18, 1943. Every time the friends would undertake a new activity, the Gestapo opened new files, new interrogations. Many “good Germans” dutifully handed over the leaflets they’d received. The Gestapo tracked every single known person on the White Rose mailing list, including recipients who had moved with no forwarding address; the Reich post office ensured those made it to investigators.

Therefore, the first bit of evidence we have that was generated by these crime lab personnel: An orderly list of recipients, their addresses, from which post office the leaflet was mailed, and exactly when the mail was picked up. As well as which leaflet the person had received.

February 1, 1943, the investigation kicked into high gear. Oberregierungsrat Schaefer, the head of the Secret State Police [GeStaPo] in Munich, assigned Agent Robert Mohr to head up this important case. Mohr’s existing caseload was transferred to other agents. He was to focus solely on these White Rose miscreants. They had not taken them seriously enough in the summer of 1942.

Schaefer assigned a team to Mohr: Mahler, Grimm, Weil, Geith, Schmauβ. These men had been Mohr’s equals. Now they reported to him. He could recruit more as needed. Schaefer advised Mohr that these leaflets “had caused very great dismay and that corre­spondingly the highest levels of the Party and govern­ment were interested in the quickest possible disposition of the case.”

They had several working theories. Because the main train station clearly was central to the distribution efforts - and the Gestapo did not fall for the ruse of leaflets mailed from other cities, because the stationery was all identical - they surmised that someone was coming to Munich from another city, likely Vienna. Munich Gestapo was already in contact with their counterparts in Vienna, who had given them a few suspects.

The most recent leaflets had been generated on BMW stationery. Entitled 30.1.33—30.1.43: Ten Years of National Socialism, this one bothered Mohr’s team the most. Agent Mohr assigned specific tasks to his crime lab:

  • Confiscate all typewriters at the BMW facility and examine them to determine which employee was responsible for the leaflets.
  • Examine BMW’s accounting records, especially purchase requisitions for office supplies, and inventory accounts for same.
  • Determine the source of the envelopes used in the other [actual White Rose] leaflet mailings.
  • Ask post offices to report on large purchases of stamps.

On February 5, Mohr penned a report to “Headquarters of Reich Security - Bureau IV A3”. Bureau IV referred to Gestapo; A to Enemies; and 3 to reactionaries and liberals. Other correspondence would go to Bureau IV A1, Communists. However, in those five short days, a powerful Nazi named Dr. Trenker joined the investigation. Mohr had no problems getting directives followed with Trenker in Munich. They did in fact determine the various envelopes used, who manufactured them, and which stores sold them. Of course, the next logical step: Get customer lists from those stores.

As an aside, Trenker was from Vienna, which likely explains the initial misdirection and looking for suspects in that city. Where coincidentally Traute Lafrenz had traveled on a recruiting mission in 1942, and where Katharina Schüddekopf’s sister and brother-in-law lived. The Gestapo strongly suspected Max Stefl, a well-known ‘subversive’ who happened to have a tangential connection to Hans Leipelt and Theodor Haecker. But not to the White Rose.

The crime lab also determined that the writers of the BMW flyers were not identical to the White Rose leaflets and returned all 1,100 typewriters to BMW. However, the Gestapo’s forensic accountants advised BMW that their accounting procedures were far too lax, as it was impossible to determine whether employees were stealing from the company.

Loyal, ‘patriotic’ store clerks, hoteliers, and boarding house owners flooded Gestapo HQ with registries. Residents of Munich described suspicious behavior, giving detailed descriptions of persons who appeared to be enemies of the State.

Yet, the Gestapo’s crime lab remained frustrated by the materials they were given. More than two weeks after the investigation started in earnest, they still had not found the typewriters used for the stencils, and for typing addresses. They knew that one typewriter had to be an American model, because it could not type the German alphabet. Instead of Weiβe Rose, the leaflets were headed WEISSE ROSE. And umlauts were created by backspacing and typing a quote mark over the vowel. But who in 1943 Germany would be using an American-made typewriter?

Mohr had collected a great deal of evidence, but was no closer to to arresting the criminals distributing these leaflets - and the graffiti! Down with Hitler, Hitler the Mass Murderer? In seventy places!, the Gestapo report stated. Including some of Munich’s most iconic NSDAP monuments. And using tar-based paint that would not come off.

On February 17, he therefore commissioned Dr. Richard Harder to create a psychological profile of the authors of the White Rose leaflets. At this time, Mohr had not realized that the first four leaflets from Summer 1942 were generated by the same people that had disseminated more powerful flyers in 1943. Harder analyzed the first four only.

Once Hans and Sophie Scholl were arrested on the 18th, the game changed. Crime lab had more evidence to analyze than they’d dreamed possible. Simultaneously, Dr. Harder delivered his report to Mohr. For profiling to have been in its infancy, he described the White Rose friends with astonishing accuracy. A day or two later when he completed the fuller report, taking the fifth and sixth leaflets into account, he nailed their essence. If they had not been arrested in the act of throwing leaflets over the balustrade, they likely would have been apprehended soon.

Agent Eduard Geith personally oversaw the search of the Scholls’ apartment. When he returned to Wittelsbacher Palais, Gestapo HQ in Munich, he sent Mohr a cursory but damning list of evidence he had found, before forwarding it to the crime lab. Massive amounts of postage stamps. Documents. Memos. Notes. A typewriter - an Erika, not the American-made machine they were looking for. A notebook full of addresses. A pistol.

Although disappointed that they still did not have the American typewriter, which they surmised to be a Remington or possibly an Underwood, the crime lab was quickly able to determine that the Erika had been used to type the addresses. The lower case e, u, s, and k, and upper case H, plus the number 4, were extraordinarily dirty. Their initial superficial examination convinced them the Erika was part of the evidence, but they would run more tests before the trial.

Note: When Agents Grimm and Müller searched Willi Graf’s room, they found nothing. It was ‘neat as a pin’ - although one of the duplicating machines was hidden there, apparently so well that they did not find it.

Once Sophie Scholl admitted that she had hidden evidence in Room 238 (likely the women’s restroom) at the university, the Gestapo searched the Atelier. Wilhelm Geyer was not present, but he immediately became a prime suspect as well. The crime lab finally had its Remington typewriter, and it had a cute little eraser holder. [The saga of this typewriter is worthy of a post all to itself, because the Volksgericht or People’s Court took a liking to it.]

On February 21, the crime lab in Munich issued its Expert Opinion for use at the trial on the 22nd. Although they could have included the stamps, and Sophie’s notebook recording cash in and expenditures for supplies and travel, they focused solely on the two typewriters. Not only did they identify which addresses were typed on the Remington Model NL 82533 M and which on the Erika Model 507540-6, and yes, they were that specific, they proved that the leaflets were typed on the Remington, on a wax stencil, using Roman type and Pica font.

The crime lab provided the prosecutors with exhibits they could use in court, photographs using red arrows to highlight peculiarities of each machine.

There will be more in future posts about the work of the crime lab between February 21 and July 13, because their scientific methodologies were advanced for those days, and give us insight into decision-making and personal interactions within the group of friends.

Perhaps the most important “gift” - for lack of a better word - the crime lab gave us? They preserved the words of the leaflets, including their evolution. As stencils would tear, texts changed. None of the friends admitted why they changed words with new versions of the leaflets. Some are subtle, but powerful. Easiest example: Prof. Kurt Huber had started his leaflet, the sixth and final, with German Students! But one night as another stencil tore and they started a new one, they changed Students to Kommilitonen, a colloquial word for ‘fellow students’ that students use among one another. Less professorial. More collegial.

Without the crime lab’s typing the six published leaflets to prove which typewriter the friends had used, their words, the words they died to defend, would have been lost.


If you are not familiar with the leaflets, all seven - the six that were published and distributed, plus Christoph Probst’s draft leaflet - can be read here in English translation on our Center for White Rose Studies Web site, on the FAQ page The Leaflets.

Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.

If you enjoyed this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!

© 2023 Denise Elaine Heap. Please contact us for permission to quote.

Image credit: My great-aunt's old Royal typewriter. © 2023 Denise Elaine Heap. Please contact us for permission to use.

The above information is fully footnoted in our White Rose histories. Please purchase them for access to that material! To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.

No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.