Operation Chastise: The Dambusters.


If you’ve read my White Rose histories, you’re aware that my version is not sanitized. I didn’t write merely about noble resistance in a vacuum of perfection. These friends were flawed. They did nothing when Jewish neighbors disappeared overnight. They did their duty when drafted, and they wrote home about what they saw and did.

Especially, these people of the resistance witnessed the burning of synagogues, the murder of neighbors. They ran for shelter when bombs fell. Käthe described herself as lucky that out of all the rooms in the building where she lived, her Studentenbude alone survived a March 1943 bombing. She promptly relocated.

Alex and Lilo outran bombs, shouting to the RAF, He’s over theeeeere, to the Osteria where Hitler had been dining as they left. That would’ve been nice.

I wrote about the horrors that Willi Graf witnessed as he alone out of all our White Rose friends saw far too much of bestiality, death, and destruction. It broke him. Had he survived, his PTSD would have done him in.

If you’ve read my White Rose histories, you’re also aware they don’t end after the February 22, 1943 trial and executions. They don’t even end after the April 19, 1943 trial. Nor after the July 13, 1943 executions. Nor after the July 13, 1943 trial. If I live long enough to write Volume III, my histories won’t even end with Willi Graf’s execution on October 12, 1943.

If you’ve read them, you know about the Nazi government’s continuing animosity towards White Rose students. Denying Käthe medical aid in prison. Re-arresting Traute and coming two days short of executing her. Tracking Herta Probst and her three small children to the mountains, to execute them and prevent Germany from “tainted blood.” Shooting Harald Dohrn in the back for his part in Freiheitsaktion Bayern, mere days before the war ended. Susanne Hirzel’s work as a servant in her own parents’ household, because she had disgraced them.

And you know about the earthquakes and massive bombing raids—not the fictional air raid of Breinersdorfer’s movie that did not happen. But the real earthquakes, the real bombing raids that affected not only registered Nazis, not merely those like Robert Scholl who were Mitläufer, and not just those Germans who “bought” Jewish goods and real estate for 1% or less of their value.

Those earthquakes, those bombing raids, also killed forced laborers, imprisoned Socialists and Jehovah’s Witnesses, those sitting on death row for supposed treason, babies, and our own people, either through friendly fire, or because they sat in POW camps subjected to air raids.

I’m therefore amplifying Gerard DeGroot’s book review, and with it, the book he reviewed. This was the part that caught my attention.

The sensitive scholar who approaches the Dambuster story is confronted by two contending sensations. First comes admiration for an incredible feat of ingenuity and courage. Then comes horror ‘at the Biblical catastrophe which Operation Chastise unleashed upon those caught in the path of the … floods’. Hastings never quite resolves the moral dilemma of these contending sensations, but there’s virtue in his equivocation. A less humane man would ignore the slaughter and celebrate that stupendous achievement. …So these men were genuine heroes – martyrs to glorious failure. But then comes a punch to the gut. Breaching those dams let loose a torrent of water travelling 18 feet per second and sweeping aside everything – cars, locomotives, houses, people. In places, the flood was 40 feet deep. Civilians, on hearing air raid sirens, took to underground shelters, the worst possible sanctuary. Perhaps 1,400 were killed, making the raid the most destructive carried out by Bomber Command up to that date.

Some might justify this slaughter as fitting retribution to followers of an evil regime. But 800 of the dead were female slave labourers – Russians, Poles, French, Ukrainians – who in no sense deserved their agony. ‘I don’t think we ever gave a thought to the people who would be drowned’, recalled one of those brave fliers. That sentiment echoes ironically through this superb book.


Here’s an excerpt from White Rose History, Volume II, Chapter 62.

Saturday May 15, [1943], the New York Times carried the story of the confiscation of Mildred Harnack nee Fish’s estate. The Swiss-based reporter had not been able to ascertain whether Mrs. Harnack had been executed along with her husband Arvid. “Only fragmentary details of the trials and identity of those implicated have been made available.” Getting news out of Germany in 1943 was nearly as difficult as listening to banned BBC broadcasts inside the country.

That Saturday, Eugen Grimminger, Heinz Bollinger, and Helmut Bauer supposedly left Munich for the penitentiary in Ludwigsburg. The paperwork submitted to the People’s Court in Berlin even showed them “gone.” But there was no movement, no matter what the paperwork said.

The RAF had been fairly quiet in the last few weeks of April. Most attacks on Berlin had been limited to sorties involving two or three “Mosquitoes.” And that would continue to be the pattern of bombing in that city in the months ahead. The nuisance factor alone was driving German citizenry crazy. On May 15, three of those single-engine planes flew sixteen sorties with no losses to the RAF, but plenty of suffering on the ground.

Then, on Sunday May 16, Bomber Command attempted their most daring raid to date. Dubbed “Operation Chastise,” newly-formed Squadron 617 attempted to breach a number of dams in Germany. Their goal: Disruption of German industrial output in the Ruhr Valley, targeting munitions factories, as well as water supply and electrical output. The RAF had designed bombs specifically for the project. “Special Forces” crews had been trained to fly at less than 100 feet above water.

Bombers succeeded in breaching three of the four dams under fire, although only two were fully destroyed, including the Eder dam, the largest dam in Europe. Loss of life on both sides was tremendous. Fifty-three members of the air crew were killed and three more captured. On the ground, “almost 1,300” reportedly people died in the ensuing floods, “including 749 Ukrainian prisoners of war based in a camp just below the Eder dam.”

The operation—later nicknamed Dambusters—may have boosted the morale of the British air force due to its spectacular success. In reality, it was a dismal failure. Germans quickly got munitions factories up and running, with no visible disruption to the war effort. And water supply was fully restored to the Ruhr Valley within six weeks.

Around 2 pm on May 16, a guard fetched Grimminger from his cell. He said nothing to the prisoner as he led him down the corridors of Stadelheim Prison. Grimminger worried that the Gestapo had re-opened his case. He did not know if he could handle another interrogation. When they emerged into Stadelheim’s outer courtyard, Helmut Bauer and Heinrich Bollinger were already waiting. They told Grimminger they were being taken away, but no one knew where.

“Every prison, no matter how terrible it is, becomes a place of security,” Grimminger recollected. “As long as one is sitting in his cell, one is safe. That security ceases when one is taken out. Where to? To the moor, to Lublin? To a concentration camp? We did not know.”


Postscript #1: In the 1980s, I met three veterans of the U.S. Air Force who had flown bomber missions during World War II. One of them, let me call him “Buddy,” had been assigned to air raids over Munich. They were instructed to drop their payloads every fifteen seconds, no matter where they were.

Since they were flying barely above the rooftops of the city, Buddy could see every child on every playground. He knew the logic behind the bombing raids, but he never outlived the nightmares. We sent “our boys” home with no understanding of the PTSD we had caused them. Buddy struggled. Luckily for us, he didn’t become a homeless veteran. He easily could have.

He was also shot down at one point and sent to a POW camp near Dresden. Yes, the same POW camp as Kurt Vonnegut, although Buddy was moved away from the Schlachthof before February. Still, the POW camp where he was transferred came under the same aerial bombardment. As he and his two friends reminisced for my benefit, one said, Hmm, that’s funny. I was part of the force that bombed Dresden in February 1945.

Buddy turned to his friend. “What?! You nearly killed me!”

Keep that in mind as you read stories of our heroic Allied soldiers and pilots and submariners. They suffered immense harm.


Postscript #2: I wish Max Hastings would write the definitive military history of what our White Rose student soldiers witnessed. And did. There are a few pretty awful books out there, most notably the almost completely inaccurate book by Detlef Bald. If you have read it and cited it in your own work, uh-oh.

Bald heavily relied on Jürgen Wittenstein’s so-called reconstructed diary entries, which I’ve deconstructed in Evolution of Memory. Wittenstein was a NS-Führungsoffizier, personally appointed by either Adolf Hitler or Heinrich Himmler. NSFOs had the sole right and authority to shoot suspected traitors on sight.

We need someone of Hastings’ stature to pry open closed or outright blocked military and denazification files. And to trace the movements of the White Rose soldier students.

I have a strong suspicion that when that is done, we will have a higher estimation of Willi Graf, Alexander Schmorell, Hubert Furtwängler, Otmar Hammerstein, Wolf Jaeger, Paul Buhl, Rudi Alt, Heinrich Bollinger, Willi Bollinger, Helmut Bauer, Werner Scholl, and a few others I may have missed.

And a devasting view of Hans Scholl, Franz Josef Müller, and Jürgen Wittenstein. It’s not for nothing that Hans Scholl enjoyed being a soldier, wanted to be an officer in Hitler’s Wehrmacht, and repeatedly sat for the officer’s exam.

Just my guess. But a fairly educated guess based on what we are allowed to see, and the gaps in that documentation.


Postscript #3: You have no idea how glad I am that Hastings’ in-depth book about Operation Chastise did not appear until 2019. That would have been a rabbit hole I may not have recovered from.

I included it because I searched the RAF’s logbooks for all air raids wherever our White Rose students and their families may have been. Dambusters showed up because of the proximity to Willi Graf’s family and friends in Saarbrücken, Bonn, and Köln.

Note: I deleted the Footnotes and References that had been part of this post on Substack. If you are interested, please purchase White Rose History, Volume II.

Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.

If you learned something from this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!

Essay © 2026 Denise Elaine Heap. Excerpts from White Rose History, Volume II, © 2002. Please contact us for permission to quote.

Image credits: Top photograph--Part of the archaeological remains called Perserschutt, or "Persian rubble": remnants of the destruction of Athens by the armies of Xerxes I. Photographed in 1866, just after excavation. Public domain. Second photograph--Photograph of the breached Möhne Dam taken by Flying Officer Jerry Fray of No. 542 Squadron from his Spitfire PR IX, six Barrage balloons are above the dam. Public domain.

Bottom photograph--Breach of the Eder Dam, May 17, 1943. German Federal Archives. Bundesarchiv, Bild 183-C0212-0043-012 / CC-BY-SA 3.0.

The above information is fully footnoted in our White Rose histories. Please purchase them for access to that material! To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.

No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.