When nonfiction collides head-on with fiction

If you have talked to me more than two minutes since February 2, 2026, you’re likely aware that I’ve been working on an autobiographical fiction novel loosely based on my growing-up years. Social media working title is Middle Earth: Houston. I am exploring how my parents were able to protect my sister and me from much of the racism and bigotry that plagued Houston in the 1950s and 1960s.

More than once, I’ve been reminded of Ernst Wiechert’s “wall of love.”

Thousands upon thousands stand around my house, a dark, loyal, steadfast wall. They demand nothing, they ask nothing. They are simply there, so I will know that they are there. So that my house shall not be hemmed in by foreign land, solitude, or bitter desolation.

Not a wall built of power or authority, but a wall of love. (Ernst Wiechert, 1937)

Wiechert’s thoughts have long influenced my White Rose work. Little-known fact, the title of the first draft of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942) was Building a Wall of Love.

Before I started writing Middle Earth: Houston, I went through my diaries from second through twelfth grades and entered those into an Excel “database.” (Sound familiar?) I also made entries based on my father’s and paternal grandmother’s extensive photo albums. For example, my fourth grade diary painted a sparse picture of our summer vacation to visit family in New Mexico. But my dad’s pictures narrated a fuller account than my five lines per day.

And I keep newspapers dot com running in the background as I write. When I mention that we went to a “festival for sixty pianos,” I look that up to provide additional context. If I’m happy that Texas A&M beat Baylor, I search for location and anything significant. (Did Aggies destroy something after that game? Any records set?) Or when I am sad that a good friend was sent to Vietnam for a second tour of duty, I find the account in the local newspaper.

However, this is historical fiction. I am writing for a non-scholarly audience. More specifically, I am writing for a target audience that expects a limited number of protagonists, that does not care about the Aggie-Baylor game unless it drives the story. Since that particular game, mentioned in my diary, was relatively unremarkable, I’ll leave it out.

Similarly, I am combining multiple people into single characters. There’s a story that I want to include in the book, because it says a great deal about who my parents were. A friend I knew for maybe all of six months gave my sister and me a present. We felt obligated to return the favor, so we used our limited funds to buy her a nice present in return.

When we opened her gift, it was a used board game with bunches of missing pieces. Nothing like the nice item we’d bought for her. Janet Kaye and I were soooo angry! We could have saved our money and purchased something nicer for another friend. She gave us a used game. And it didn’t even have all the pieces!

My mother sat us down and patiently explained that Trish’s* mom could barely pay the rent. Friends often supplied groceries, without fanfare, without making a fuss about it. Trish and her mom lived in a horrible little apartment—Janet and I had been there once—that wasn’t even 250 square feet in total. *All names changed throughout.

“She gave you something that meant a lot to her, something that would connect you two to her. Her present cost her more than what you bought her, because she gave up something she liked.”

No way I am leaving that out. But we only knew Trish for a few months. Lost contact with her after that. So I am keeping the story, but “giving” it to another friend. Since we grew up in inner city Houston, many elementary school friends were in the same boat.

I’m also excluding about half our cousins. My father’s mother’s father had nine children, six of whom lived to adulthood. My mother’s mother’s mother had nine children, who all lived well into old age. Simple mathematics explains why family reunions could be overwhelming. Readers would get confused if I included all of them. Choosing a few, and letting them stand in for the rest.

Same with school friends. I’m Gen Jones, which meant large, large school populations. Our high school alone had five thousand students. I probably knew 150 or so reasonably well. Can you imagine a novel with 150 characters, even fringe characters? I’m being picky about who represents the entire circle.

Then there’s events to consider. My dad had a one-night stand when I was in first grade that nearly killed my mother. I could easily leave it out. But it’s part of the story, so I am choosing not to do so.

I’m also including the incest in a family we knew, where an alcoholic husband raped four of his five daughters. People who were named Not My Family praised that man for being so godly, so moral, so upright. When he died, he was eulogized as a man of god who loved his family. Anyone who knew about the incest gossiped that it was either his wife’s fault or that his daughters were asking for it. My parents made sure we knew neither wife nor daughters were to blame!

As with Trish’s story, I’m including it, but ensuring that the family is not identifiable. I’m changing their back story, lifestyle, and circle of friends. There’s no way I want to embarrass those beautiful girls, who are now old women like me. If I could out their father without humiliating them, I would.

His story, and the abuse those girls endured, is included solely to underscore the depravity of what passes for religion in many cult-like communities.

And I am changing names. Am I ever changing names! Some of those cousins are litigious. Plus, it is fictionalized, so I don’t want anyone assuming that e.g., Leah said or did the exact things attributed to her. Leah will be a combination of Rachel, Deborah, and Ruth. If I used Leah’s real name but attached her to a thing Rachel did, she could possibly sue me for defamation. And last thing I want is a defamation lawsuit.

Although this is a novel, not a history, I decided not to ignore events that shaped my family, even the painful ones. Especially the painful ones. I will be dealing with my sister’s suicide. With my paternal grandmother’s breakdown after divorcing her abusive husband. With great-uncles who used the n-word. With cousins who smoked and drank behind the very-real barn. With a great-aunt who ruined every family event she attended. Our “wall of love” gave us as much protection as humanly possible.

Since this is a novel, not a history, I am also writing the delightful stories. Getting our first puppy. Spending Thanksgivings with my beloved great-grandmother, Minnie Lea Norris. Family vacations to New Mexico and Colorado, including driving the Million Dollar Highway more than once. School, school, and always school. I lucked into the best teachers ever.

And I am balancing the good, the bad, and the ugly, keeping in mind: This is a novel, not a history.

To summarize: I am writing a historical fiction novel, loosely based on my childhood and teen years, but changing facts to accommodate the constraints of the genre.

And I am having a lot of fun doing so.

Because—that is exactly what I could not do when writing those White Rose histories. I was able to identify ninety-odd people who were involved with White Rose one way or the other, plus another thirty or more Gestapo agents, defense attorneys, and prosecutors handling their arrests and trials.

Since my White Rose books were history, not a novel, I couldn’t use only Agents Robert Mohr and Schmauβ. No. There’s Gestapo agents Achter, Ammer, Barth, Beer, Berger, Engelbrecht, Geisser, Geith, Grimm, Gstetner, Hermannsdörfer, Hofmann, Mahler, Müller, Rechtsteiner, Selber, Stolch, Trenker, and Zacher. And clerks who signed interrogation transcripts included, but were not limited to, Elfriede Maier, Huppeitz, Schuster, plus agents Schmauβ and Berger. Don’t even get me started on those who worked in the prisons who treated White Rose students—and the adults who labored alongside them—mostly harshly, who stole their money, who betrayed their dying words to the Gestapo.

Since my White Rose books were history, not a novel, I couldn’t limit the characters to an easy group. It’s frustrating enough when supposed historians don’t include all twenty-one persons indicted and tried for the original White Rose work (that is, not including the group around Hans Leipelt in Munich’s chemistry department). If you read a book and it does not include ALL of the following, immediately question the legitimacy of their research. Because all of these individuals were arrested and tried for one form of treason or another.

Helmut Bauer, Heinz Bollinger, Harald Dohrn, Manfred Eickemeyer, Wilhelm Geyer, Willi Graf, Eugen Grimminger, Heinrich Guter, Falk Harnack, Hans Hirzel, Susanne Hirzel, Prof. Dr. Kurt Huber, Traute Lafrenz, Franz Josef Müller, Christoph Probst, Gisela Schertling, Hans Scholl, Sophie Scholl, Alexander Schmorell, Katharina Schüddekopf, and Josef Söhngen.

That is the baseline. Any “White Rose” book that does not include these twenty-one people is not worth a plug nickel.

Truly substantive research will also include friends such as Lilo Ramdohr, Hubert Furtwängler, Raimund Samüller, Otmar Hammerstein, Rudi Alt, and many, many more. They escaped because their friends protected them, did not say their names. Because of them, we know more about the twenty-one, if we’re willing to listen.

You may be asking: All well and good, Denise. Nice to know you’re staying busy. What does all this have to do with White Rose?

Good question, I will reply: Because the bases of all White Rose research, past and present, seem to be grounded firmly in Inge Scholl’s little book and subsequent interviews about her book, as well as Jürgen Wittenstein’s 1947 essay and the multitude of essays that followed in the 1990s, especially his revisionist History Place essay.

As I am learning with Middle Earth: Houston, it’s downright fun when dialog does not have to be rooted in fact. I can take our true-life Saturday at Hermann Park and the Houston Zoo and invent dialog around it, no questions asked. Since I’m conscious of limiting characters, we are only there with one family, not with three. And I don’t have to worry about whether we really and truly got milkshakes at Prince’s Hamburgers on that particular day. We often did so, and no one will be fact-checking.

The same does not hold true with books that purport to document a historical record, like Inge Scholl and Jürgen Wittenstein insisted they were doing. Like my own father, Inge’s father had trouble staying faithful to Magdalena Scholl. The Scholls were run out of Forchtenberg because of an affair he had in Sophie’s hometown. But Inge conveniently left that out, pretending they had a perfect family. When the Scholl family was probably the most dysfunctional of all White Rose families.

Inge seems to have thought she was writing a historical fiction novel. She collapsed the circle of friends in Ulm down to one or two, neglecting to mention that Sophie apparently shunned Annelies Kammerer after Annelies’ father was declared a “Jewish lackey” by The Powers That Be. And Inge invented a nonexistent Jewish friend for Sophie. The girl existed all right, but not as Sophie’s friend, and certainly not with blond hair and blue eyes, as Inge related in her novel, I mean White Rose “history.” Of course I am speaking of Luise Nathan. Who was in fact a friend of Susanne Hirzel.

Once Hans and Sophie arrived in Munich, Inge performed the same disappearing act on the large circle of friends at the university. She purported to write a White Rose “history,” and yet ignored most of those twenty-one wonderful people and the others they cared about.

What makes Inge’s little “White Rose” book so egregious to me: She knew the truth. For her, it was not a matter of ignorance. She had forty-seven (47) letters, some quite long and detailed, describing their work, who did what, the much larger group of friends who made resistance possible. And she chose to disregard any part of those forty-seven letters that did not focus on her siblings. Correction: That did not focus on Hans and Sophie Scholl.

Inge also chose to ignore Elisabeth and Werner Scholl. According to Inge’s own husband Otl Aicher, Werner was the first Scholl to resist. Werner struck up close friendships with Willi Graf and Alexander Schmorell on the Russian front, and with Traute Lafrenz in February 1943. Traute told me that Werner was the only independent thinker in the Scholl family. Sophie gleaned much of her philosophy of life from her younger brother Werner. You’d never know any of that from Inge’s book.

Nor did Inge mention Elisabeth’s strong political leanings towards socialism, if not outright Communism, a political leaning she shared with Werner. Those two siblings, often joined by Sophie but not Hans, spent much time with Richard Scheringer, an outspoken Communist who lived near Ulm on his farm (Dürrnhof). End of 1942, beginning of 1943, Elisabeth worked as the Scheringers’ nanny. Sophie’s last trip to Ulm in February 1943, she visited her sister at Dürrnhof. After the execution of Hans and Sophie, Ulmers referred to Elisabeth as “the Communist Scholl.” Not a compliment.

Why isn’t that in Inge’s book? Elisabeth didn’t try to hide it.

Nor were the protests Fritz Hartnagel and Elisabeth Hartnagel nee Scholl lodged with Inge over falsehoods in her book ever taken into account. When I interviewed them in their home, they ensured that I knew what those falsehoods were. I’ll never forget Elisabeth’s angry—soft-spoken, but angry—statement: “I was there, and she was not!”

Elisabeth did in fact spend two weeks in 1943 in Munich with Hans and Sophie. She did not participate in the leaflet operation, but she was there as they discussed it. She was there when Alex changed into his “Russian” clothes to feed forced laborers with his friend Nikolay. She was at Theodor Haecker’s February 4 reading. She was there for at least one, if not two, of the graffiti operations, witnessing the after-party that Inge totally botched in her telling. She sat in Huber’s classes with all of them. And Inge would not accept her testimony as valid. (That’s why Elisabeth sent me the forty-seven documents. She was afraid her sister would destroy them.)

I have plotted my autobiographical fiction novel, Middle Earth: Houston. If I change something up, I note that in my outline. I add notes from newspaper articles with date and title and keep a printed and digital PDF as backup. The “indignation rallies” are a prime example. Should the Internet collapse onto itself one day, I want documentation for something that feels beyond absurd sixty years later.

Inge’s ten-page typed outline? She picked and chose only White Rose events that featured Hans and Sophie. If you’ve only read her work, or only read work (e.g., Hermann Vinke, Dumbach/Newborn, Richard Hanser) that is based on Inge’s little book or interviews with her, you’d never know that Wilhelm Geyer ate breakfast every day with Hans and Sophie those first six weeks of 1943. Often dinner as well (he paid). And that he would sometimes bring Gerhard Feuerle with him for those breakfasts or dinners. Inge knew that. But it featured someone besides her siblings.

She also had Deisinger’s wonderful letter about the executions of Alexander Schmorell and Kurt Huber. And Traute’s six-page document about her relationship and breakup with Hans. And Lisa Grote’s report about receiving the leaflets (likely from Alex or Kurt Huber) and painstakingly copying them out and distributing them in the park to fellow nannies. And Lilo’s stories about the beauty of those friendships. And… you get the picture.

Inge Scholl treated the White Rose story in general, and her siblings’ “biographies” in particular, as historical fiction, where she could freely invent dialog and substitute characters as she wished.

If you’ve ever seen the Michael Verhoeven movie, you’ve witnessed one such invention that sets my teeth on edge. The hilarious and poignant scene with Alex and Sophie riding their bicycles during an air raid? That was LILO and Alex. Inge forced Verhoeven to change it to Sophie, or she threatened to withhold permission to use “her” photographs in the movie. Lilo showed me the original screenplay.

Wittenstein’s fiction is even worse. Since the friends avoided him—he proudly wore his NSDAP membership pin in public—he relied greatly on Inge and those forty-seven letters, evidently in exchange for use of his photographs. Plus apparently the OSS (now CIA) granted him access to the Gestapo interrogation transcripts. In 1946 or 1947. He referenced that access more than once.

IN SUMMARY

If you have “fallen in love” with the White Rose story, or with any other historical event that features uncommon courage, you must decide whether you are writing historical fiction or nonfiction. If you want to write nonfiction, you may not leave anything out. Let’s say you want to write about the group in Hamburg, a decidedly depressing subject, since they betrayed Traute in 1944, thinking it would save their own skins.

If you choose that topic, get all of them, good, bad, ugly, inspiring, untrustworthy, brave. Include their mentors like Rudolf Degkwitz. Paint their ups and downs. Don’t be satisfied with the legend that Inge Scholl and Jürgen Wittenstein created about Hamburg’s being “successor to White Rose resistance.”

Those people in Hamburg, Traute’s friends, were practicing informed dissent and passive resistance while Hans Scholl was still pompously leading his Hitler Youth group and Sophie was hobnobbing with Inge’s BDM leadership friends. They rescued Jewish neighbors, distributed Thomas Mann’s Responsa, and held seditious literary soirees. Traute brought their resistance to Munich, not the other way around.

Believe me, it’s way more fun writing historical fiction, even when the topic can be grim. I grew up in Houston when Birchers were everywhere, when Houston Independent School District tried every trick in their book not to comply with desegregation laws, when there were still “whites only” water fountains at Henke & Pillot.

Although I am paying attention to detail, it’s not the same as writing those White Rose Histories, where facts are important, where I operated from the position that every life mattered, where I believed Elisabeth and Fritz when they told me, “Hans and Sophie were NOT the leaders.”

If you are writing nonfiction, take care that your words avoid a collision with fictional events. Look at Inge Scholl and Jürgen Wittenstein. And do the opposite.


Postscript: There is a difference between straight nonfiction and creative nonfiction. The latter does indeed permit fact-based dialog and “imagined” scenes based on actual documents. Even with creative nonfiction, writers must resist the urge to discredit their research by inventing too much.

COMMENTS WORTH KEEPING

Love this article, Denise! It makes me even more excited about your novel-in-progress since you are putting so much effort into getting the story right.

--Gwen Miertschin, July 17, 2026.

Denise, you keep mentioning the photographs and then moving on. Look at what's under them. Verhoeven has to turn Lilo into Sophie or he doesn't get the pictures. Wittenstein comes to her for the letters because the surviving friends won't touch him. The man wore his party pin in public.

But it's bigger than the photographs, and you already handed me the proof. Dumbach and Newborn thank her for permission to quote the letters. That's the whole game right there. She didn't just write the story wrong. She owned the paper you'd need to write it right, and she rented it out to people who'd keep her siblings in the center.

Vinke, Hanser, all of them working off a source that had already cut twenty-one down to two before they sat down.

Inventing was never the crime. You said it yourself, declare the genre and invent all you want. The crime is she made herself the only way in. You don't get to the Scholls except through her version.

Anyway, still can't get over Geyer paying for those breakfasts.

--Vance Frost, July 17, 2026.

My response to Vance Frost: Thank you for this! That "only way in" won't last forever. The blocked Scholl archives do have a time limit, although it cannot come soon enough. And one day--again, not soon enough--the CIA and NARA will get tired of ignoring my FOIA requests and I will be able to write the truth about Wittenstein's photographs.

Until I have documentation in hand, I 'know' the truth, but cannot write it without fear of being sued into oblivion by his children. Who benefit greatly from royalties they receive from Getty Images.

[Irony of ironies: Wittenstein and Inge Scholl were joined at the hip by the blackmail they had on one another. But Wittenstein was furious that Inge Scholl had stamped "Copyright Scholl Archives" on every single photograph he lent her for her book. Ha!] -- July 17, 2026.

Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.

If you enjoyed this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!

© 2026 Denise Elaine Heap. Please contact us for permission to quote.

Image credits: Shopify, public domain for platform users. Please Buy Me A Coffee!

To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.

No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.