Songs of a forgotten revolution

On July 4, we celebrate the anniversary of an audacious experiment. After years of grumbling, thinkers and philosophers and lawyers joined farmers, clergymen, merchants, and yes, plantation owners to breathe life into a democracy. In Philadelphia, these men wrote words we still hold dear.

In Congress, July 4, 1776.

The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America, When in the Course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the Laws of Nature and of Nature’s God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation. (National Archives. Declaration of Independence: A Transcript.)

It says something about the power of those words, the ideas embodied by those words, the resolution of the men—and women—who brought them to life, that over the course of the next fifty or seventy-five years, other nations followed suit.

France (1789-1799). Belgium (The Brabant Revolution, 1789-1790). Haiti (1791-1804). Ireland (1798). Serbia (1804-1835). Greece (1821-1829). Belgium (1830-1831). Poland (1830-1831). Germany and Austria (1832-1848).

Germany and Austria? As Germans would say, Doch! Or, certainly!

The German push for overthrow of the monarchy and institution of democracy saw the light of day in April 1833. It had been brewing for years, as professors and students read French and American texts and understood that the tyranny of the über-rich—those dukes and lords and kings who saw themselves as divinely anointed and owed great wealth by the common man—did not have to be tolerated.

Leaders of the April 1833 operation believed they had the support of the masses. After all, in 1832, 30,000 of their fellow citizens had joined them at the Hambach Festival in the Rhineland, swearing the oath immortalized by Friedrich Schiller in Wilhelm Tell. “We would sooner die than live in slavery!”

The first of several German democratic-revolutionary folk songs originated at that 1832 festival. Fürsten, zum Land hinaus [link opens performance on YouTube], a protest song with the usual call-and-response structure that enables easy singing along, explicitly demanded running the princes out of the country. “Now comes the people’s feast!”

Whoever the lyricist may have been—Sauerwein?—they pulled no punches. The bard named the principality and its associated prince in each verse. I’m guessing the first time this song was sung, the protesters in the Rhineland took special pleasure in calling out Bavaria. Ludwig is good for nothing, shoot the dog. Similar vitriol took aim at Friedrich Wilhelm III, king of Prussia, denouncing him as a murderer of citizens.

If the leaders of the would-be German revolution thought censorship had been bad before, the monarchy ensured it worsened. Whereas printers had been required to submit proposed print projects to a central censorship committee before 1832, after the Hambach Festival the unified princes instituted a network of informants and spies to report printers who failed to comply. Freedom of the press? Not in mid-19th century Germany.

Although German princes came together to ensure that the 1832 movement was put down, organizers of the revolution didn’t give up. April 3, 1833, forty or fifty students along with a few teachers stormed two guardhouses in Frankfurt. Although the attack was loosely organized, the participants came from a number of student associations.

In addition to making a visible statement, they also wished to control Frankfurt’s treasury, free political prisoners, and arrest members of the German Confederation, which had its seat in Frankfurt. They counted on backing from the student bodies in Frankfurt, Heidelberg, and Würzburg, where they’d enjoyed tremendous and—they thought—enthusiastic support.

Although German students stayed home, an unusual band of insurgents aided the Germans storming the guardhouses. Several student leaders in Frankfurt had traveled to Poland in 1831 to assist Poles injured in their November Revolution. Although the Polish fight for independence and democracy was snuffed out, they did not forget their German comrades. Polish revolutionaries fled their homeland, landing in Frankfurt among friends. In Frankfurt, these Poles were hailed as heroes. “The Poles carried the sacred fire to the west of Europe, and the flame of enthusiasm has been burning brightly on German soil ever since,” wrote Friedrich Moritz von Wagemann.

The democrats, German and Polish alike, were betrayed and easily captured. Or fled and lived in exile.

Of those who were captured, six managed a daring jailbreak on January 10, 1837, immediately becoming the stuff of legend... And a great protest song, Die freie Republik. [Lyrics are transcribed on the linked performance, my primary reason for choosing this version.] As with much protest music—think Battle Hymn of the Republic—the composer and lyricist drew on an extant, familiar song. Many renditions maintain an almost martial air, Sousa-style. I prefer the lighter Pete Seeger flair.

And of course, there’s plenty of debate over whether those six students were in prison for a role in the 1833 insurrection, or whether they’d been sentenced for a similar but unrelated offense. It did not matter to the ongoing democracy movement in Germany. By 1848, Die freie Republik had become part of their “hymnal.”

As an aside, because this is a golden thread through the ages: Although much of the rhetoric from 1832-1848 was heated and inflammatory, a decent number of writers used humor and satire to make their points. Die freie Republik exemplifies this aspect, as the first several verses ridicule the jailers and soldiers who boasted about the security of their prison.

The haha nature of the song stops in the last two verses.

Und wenn sie euch nun fragen: “Wo ist Absalom?” Dann dürft ihr ihnen sagen: “Ja der hänget schon!” Er hängt an keinem Baume, er hängt an keinem Strick, sondern an dem Glauben der freien Republik!

English: And should they now ask you: “Where is Absalom?” Then you may tell them: “Well, he’s already hanging [been hanged]!” He’s not hanging from a tree, he’s not hanging from a rope, but from* the faith of the free republic! [*This is a delicious pun in German, because to hang someone, e.g., death penalty, the verb is anhängen, “to hang from.” But when used with faith or a concept like democracy, it means “he clings to his faith in the free republic.” An Anhänger is a disciple, a hanger-on.]

I am trying to keep this relatively short. Each event, each person deserves much fuller attention. For example, in March 1834, twenty-one-year-old Georg Büchner wrote Der Hessische Landbote [The Hessian Courier], a simple eight-page pamphlet. He borrowed from the French revolution, but drew heavily on personal experience as a student. He told his parents, “I was ashamed to be a servant among servants, to please a decaying princely family and a groveling civil servant aristocracy.”

Büchner turned his shame into words worthy of Thomas Paine. He saw their fight as one not merely for democracy or for the dissolution of the monarchy. No! It was a fight for human rights. He and a fellow student named their student association Gesellschaft der Menschenrechte or Society for Human Rights. Friedrich Ludwig Weidig, an irreverent and revolutionary Lutheran pastor, edited Büchner’s pamphlet and reissued it a few months later with even stronger words, even more passion.

Weidig considered Jesus not as a powerful God, but rather someone “who fought against the injustice and hypocrisy of the powerful of his time.” You can imagine how that went over in 1834!

The regional princes issued warrants for the arrests of Büchner and Weidig. Büchner managed to escape to Switzerland. But Weidig—imprisoned in Darmstadt—was tortured, held without trial. Less than two years later, Weidig died in prison. He wrote on the walls of the cell, in his own blood: “Since the enemy denies me any defense, I choose a shameful death of my own free will.” Yes, he suicided. On February 23, 1837, at the age of forty-six.

His friend and fellow democrat Georg Büchner had died of typhus in Switzerland four days earlier, on February 19, 1837, only twenty-three. He may have been young, but he was a physician (M.D. and PhD!) and taught courses in “cranial nerves.” In addition to his writing on behalf of human rights, he also has been praised for his use of psychoanalysis in his novels.

Despite the deaths of two influential members of Germany’s struggle for freedom, these defeated rebels would not give up so easily. In 1848, German freedom fighters joined in, if not led, the democratic uprisings that swept across much of Europe. France’s own “February Revolution” in 1848 resulted in the abdication of King Louis-Philippe of France.

The German struggle gained a third fighting song that drew on Die freie Republik for inspiration, especially the wordplay with “hanging.” A thirty-seven-year-old lawyer and “radical” named Friedrich Karl Franz Hecker, together with Gustav [von] Struve, led the insurgency in the German state of Baden. That particular campaign failed and Hecker fled to Illinois in exile, while Struve went to Philadelphia. [Struve renounced his noble status and stopped using “von” in his family name.]

Hecker’s followers turned Die freie Repuplik into a militaristic, somewhat gruesome battle cry. It would be impossible to miss their point. Not with the demands to hang the aristocracy from the priest’s bowels or call to grease the guillotine with the tyrant’s fat and tear the concubine from the prince’s bed. The “Heckerlied” [link is to performance on YouTube] also made a bloody reference that would be taken out of context and used by Nazis less than one hundred years later: Fürstenblut muss flieβen stiefeldick. Nazis would use that line, substituting “Juden” or Jews for Fürsten [princes].

Perhaps precisely because it was such a macabre text set to a bellicose, beerhall tune, the Heckerlied served as rallying cry for the duration of the 1848 revolt.

Indeed, it seemed that this time, Germany was finally going to get her democracy. The March 1848 uprisings caused not only many of its ruling monarchs to flee the country, most taking refuge in England, but by May 1, 1848, the unbelievable had occurred: Germans went to the polls to cast votes for their first-ever real parliament, the Frankfurter Nationalversammlung [Frankfurt National Assembly]. Hecker and his militia may have lost the battle, but they won the war.

Sidenote: In April and early May 1848, the Frankfurter Nationalversammlung was technically controlled by the princes of the extant German Confederation. Therefore the May 1848 election was more than a little suspect, with princes trying to influence the vote. In some cases, regions or localities simply made up the rules as they went along, because the constitution did not yet exist. Marshall Dill noted that each region was therefore not fairly represented, with Austria underrepresented, and Hesse overrepresented. “It is astonishing that in the chaotic state of affairs such a distinguished body of men could be brought together.” (Dill)

Nevertheless: Every German state was represented. They had done it! They got their long-desired constitution, guaranteeing human rights, freedom of speech, and an end to censorship! They tossed a bone to the ruling powers, defining their new democracy as a constitutional monarchy, similar to the United Kingdom, which would be led by a figurehead, a hereditary “emperor.”

Most German fiefdoms accepted the new world order. Prussia did not. However, by the time the installation of members of parliament occurred, the Prussian contingent was there.

Writers such as Juda Löb Baruch (aka Ludwig Börne), Friedrich Wilhelm Schulz, and Karl Buchner, along with a few brave pastors, both Catholic and Lutheran, wrote the words that ignited and sustained this democratic revolution. Lawyers and demagogues gave fiery speeches, uniting the German populace, ALL of the German populace, under a single flag, the black-red-gold of a new country, a new, unified people. It was a heady time to be alive.

Until it wasn’t.

The rest of the world would not accept the new constitutional government. Only three countries officially recognized the new Germany: The Netherlands, Switzerland, and the USA. Everyone else opposed its formation. The first German Navy was organized in June 1848 in response to a dispute with Denmark, with Russia and Britain supporting Denmark (the First Schleswig War).

By May 1849, infighting in Frankfurt among the members of parliament, together with resurgence of the monarchy in places like Austria and Prussia, and unrest among the working classes, caused Europe’s newest democracy to crumble.

Although the new constitution had greatly benefited working-class Germans, they didn’t see it that way. While philosophers, lawyers, and clergy celebrated human rights, freedom of the press, and liberation from feudal power, “peasants” only knew that their standard of living had not improved. They did not want great words while Germany still had an emperor and the local lord had not been removed from his castle.

Between parliamentarian infighting and unrest among those outside the ruling “class” in Frankfurt, Germany’s new republic and democracy didn’t stand a chance. Kings and princes found it easy to sway public sentiment, either by force or with empty promises. It didn’t help matters when Russia sent its military to assist German princes in “keeping the peace.”

By the end of 1849, Germany’s great experiment had ended. Power was once again concentrated in the hands of the monarchy and their ministers. Although some of the kingdoms like Bavaria technically retained the constitution written in Frankfurt in 1848, they stripped the document of language that could possibly weaken the king.

As Hecker had lost the battle but won the war, the kings and princes of Germany lost the revolution but gained more power than they’d ever had. Germany would enter a century of war, war, and more war, with alliances malleable and unstable.


Who actually won, then, the German Revolution of 1848?

The biggest winner by far: The United States of America. Some of the Forty-Eighters, as they would be called, replanted themselves in South America or Australia. Chile. Brazil. Victoria.

But the USA? Cream of the crop. They settled in Texas: Boerne (see photo), New Braunfels, Bellville, the Hill Country. They settled in Cincinnati. They settled in Chicago. They settled in Milwaukee, oh, did they ever settle in Milwaukee!

And they brought with them the noble ideals that drove them to take a stand in their homeland.

Abolitionists all, wherever they settled they fought to free slaves. And they signed up en masse for the U.S. Army during the Civil War, even when they lived in a state (like Texas) that had seceded.

Most, even among the clergy, were not especially religious and embraced separation of church and state in America, something they’d never known in Germany. When the Catholic church sent an emissary to Cincinnati in 1853, the Forty-Eighters rioted.

The Forty-Eighters became prominent politicians, lawyers, professors. They agitated for labor unions and the inalienable rights of workers. They were doctors, medical researchers, journalists, businessmen. They established newspapers and magazines. They brought the German notion of kindergarten to the USA. The Turner among them—revolutionary gymnasts and educators—founded Turnvereine in the USA. The one in Los Angeles is still going strong, 178 years later. A Sound Mind in a Sound Body.

Our friend Friedrich Hecker became an outspoken abolitionist in Illinois. Hecker along with another slightly familiar person—Abraham Lincoln—would have been an elector from Illinois in 1856 had John Frémont won the presidency. Frémont lost to James Buchanan, so Hecker didn’t get to cast an electoral vote alongside Lincoln.

In the early days of the civil war, Hecker commanded the 24th Illinois Infantry Regiment, comprised almost solely of Forty-Eighters. By 1862, he was colonel of the 82nd Illinois Infantry Regiment, Forty-Eighters plus immigrants from other countries.

Hecker remained a German at heart, until a return visit in 1873. He traveled back to his homeland to celebrate Germany’s defeat of France in the Franco-Prussian War. While there, he criticized lack of human rights in Germany. And, as he should have expected, “Germany” was more than happy to ship him back to the USA.

After that, Friedrich Hecker celebrated his life as an American. He stayed entrenched in Illinois politics. His fans and followers sported the “Hecker hat,” a slouch hat worn by the Austrian military and later popularized by Teddy Roosevelt’s Rough Riders.

They also sang the Heckerlied, although I could not find whether they sang it in German and English. I’d wager German. There were plenty of Forty-Eighters in Illinois.


Postscript #1: If you are interested in protest songs, Songs for a Revolution by Eckhard John and David Robb would likely be an excellent addition to your library. In this post, I’ve talked about only three of the twenty-two songs they dissect and analyze.

Many songs of the revolution were based on extant folk music. Schlaf, mein Kind, schlaf leis. Frisch auf, mein Volk, mit Trommelschlag. Sah ein Fürst ein Büchlein stehn. Especially when the revolutionary lyrics were call-and-response, or simple and repetitive, the “folk” source made them readily accepted by the masses.

Interesting too how much of the material was recycled over the next one-hundred years. The recycling didn’t merely impact protest movements. Wandervogel and other bündische groups adapted the songs of 1830-1849, modifying the lyrics to match the era.


Postscript #2: I”ve written before about the moral dilemmas associated with informed dissent, with resistance.

In Moral dilemmas, I identified the five hard questions White Rose students faced, things they talked about and recorded in their diaries and correspondence. Was “inner emigration” all right? As soldiers, were they bound by their oath of loyalty to Adolf Hitler? What about Romans 13? What form should their resistance efforts take? And finally, is assassination ever acceptable?

In Moral dilemmas – the hard topics, I defined the difference between informed dissent and a “summer of discontent.” That post included thoughts about the justification for active resistance (violence) as opposed to passive or nonviolent resistance.

In Moral dilemmas – the hard topics, continued, I addressed the tougher part of the five hard questions, including assassination. In Moral roadblock: “Romans 13”, well yes, you guessed it, that’s the topic (and it only applies to Christians who take the Christian Bible literally, not to anyone else).

And finally, in Where there are no worthy persons..., I share a moving article by Rabbi Michael Singer, then of Malverne, New York. He asked the question: If I was not Jewish and was living in Germany during the time of the Shoah, would I have risked my life by hiding Jews or actively resisting the Nazis?

Those same considerations apply to the German Revolution of 1848/1849, indeed, to our own American Revolution. Perhaps this is indeed healthy reading for July 4?


For further reading:

This is not my area of expertise. I have read a great deal about it ever since I stumbled across Die freie Republik in 2003. The parallels to White Rose resistance struck me as noteworthy. At that time, it did not seem too relevant in American politics.

Things have changed…

If this IS your area of expertise and if I’ve misstated or misspoken, please correct me either via message or in a comment. It’s too important to mess up.


Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.

If you enjoyed this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!

© 2026 Denise Elaine Heap. Please contact us for permission to quote.

Image credit: Top image--Shopify, public domain for platform users. Second image--The Frankfurter Wachensturm uprising on April 3, 1833. Reproduction of a coloured woodcarving by Francois Georgin (1801-1863), Epinal (Original now at the Historical Museum, Frankfurt am Main). Public domain.

Third image--Picture of the fights between revolutionaries and the royal military in the Breite Strasse Street, Berlin during the March 1848 revolution. Artist unknown. Drawn between 1848-1850. Public domain. Fourth image--Main Street in Boerne, Texas ca 1890-1900. Public domain.

To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.

No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.

Reichstag (Parliament), Berlin, Germany. April 21, 2016. Photographer: Diego Delso. delso.photo, License CC BY-SA.