In Memoriam: Alexander Held (October 19, 1958 – May 12, 2026)

This short in memoriam is harder to write than I thought it would be. And I’m having to write it ten or more years before I’m ready to do so.
September 2007, my mom Joyce Light and I gladly accepted Igor Khramov’s invitation to participate in the commemoration of Alexander Schmorell’s ninetieth birthday in Orenburg, Russia. In 2007, I did not know Igor. Had never heard of him.
But Erich Schmorell knew me, and Erich Schmorell knew Igor. As Erich tended to do, he connected us, reaching out to Igor and telling him, “You simply must invite Denise Heap!” Neither Igor nor I could ever say no to Erich. Or Hertha.
Both Ulrich Chaussy and Alexander Held attended as well. They were fresh off their “success” with Fred Breinersdorfer’s pretty awful movie about Sophie Scholl. Interestingly, and this endeared Igor to me, the photo ops and autograph parties took place before the conference began. By the time I and other researchers landed in Orenburg, that part was finished.
Which meant we worked with students at the university in Orenburg on nitty gritty topics. They had already had their celebrity moments. Now it was time to talk shop.
Igor had retained an interpreter for German to Russian, since most scholars were from Germany. As we spoke auf Deutsch, she interpreted so everyone would understand. At one point I could not remember a German phrase (a joke) to save my life. So I said it in English. 100% of the students laughed. They got it.
I was aware that Alexander Held was a big deal in German television and film. In addition to playing Gestapo agent Robert Mohr in the Breinersdorfer movie, he had also played SS-Brigadeführer Walther Hewel in the German movie Der Untergang (English: Downfall). Check out his IMDb profile. You’ve probably seen him in movies, or on German TV, and didn’t know it. Most recently, he starred in München Mord and Baltic Crime Watch.
Therefore I was caught off guard by his self-effacing nature. I’m sure this won’t be a surprise to anyone who knows me, but I hung out with the troublemakers.
- Nikolay Daniel Nikolaeff-Hamazaspian, good friend to both Alexander Schmorell and Lilo Ramdohr.
- Winfrid Vogel, who had helped Igor network with German funding as part of his lifelong ambition for reconciliation between Germany and Russia. [He was the #1 ‘troublemaker’ at that conference! Such a fun man.]
- Rustam Galimov, who kept/keeps Igor in line.
- Igor’s wife Dilya, extraordinary woman and an EnglishóRussian translator who’s amazing and fun.
- Whoever my mom drew into her circle. I learned more about Siberia, borscht, history, literature, and Russian culture from the people who loved her laugh and sat at table with us.
- And, Alexander Held.When Alexander Held was in the spotlight, he was in the spotlight. He commanded a podium. But when he wasn’t? Not once during that entire week did he upstage someone else. He seemed to be one of those people who celebrates others’ successes.

Quick example: We had all been going 100 mph. Igor packed a lot into a week. My mom had grown tired and needed space. She and I therefore headed to the bus.
A few minutes later, Alexander Held climbed onboard. The bus, which could seat 50+ passengers, was empty except for my mom and me. She put her head against the window. I sat in the aisle seat, reading. Alexander Held sat down in the aisle seat next to me, leaned back, and closed his eyes.
We sat quietly for a good fifteen minutes. When he stirred, I asked him, “It must be hard having to be ‘up’ all the time. Are you all right?”
He said he was and thanked me for noticing. Brief chitchat, nothing much, just two people glad to be away from the wonderful hubbub, if only for a few minutes.
Alexander Held and I never became penpals, much less close friends. I kept up with his career and celebrated from a distance when he got a new role or when his series was renewed for another season. I laughed at his (or his social media person’s) puns and running gags. His use of social media kept him at the back of my mind, always a reminder of a most excellent week in Orenburg, Russia.
I had gone to Orenburg disappointed that Ulrich Chaussy and Alexander Held would be there. Breinersdorfer’s film squandered an opportunity that few get. Chaussy is usually a great researcher and scholar. Most of his work is impeccable.
But he bought into the legend at the last minute. The things he knew to be true, he ignored. The things he knew to be false, he kept. If anyone knew how Mohr should be portrayed in 2007, it was Ulrich Chaussy. He had interviewed Robert Mohr’s son. And ignored all that that son told him, or allowed Breinersdorfer to ignore it, without protesting.
I had assumed that Alexander Held was responsible for the inaccurate and flat-out-wrong portrayal of Robert Mohr, the Gestapo agent who interrogated Sophie Scholl, as a basically nice guy. For the record, Robert Mohr was a nice guy same as Michael Flynn and Roger Stone and Jeffrey Epstein are (or were) nice guys.
Alexander Held had the acting chops to carry off a portrayal of Robert Mohr as sugary sweet and deadly, saccharine and vicious. I was wrong to believe it was Held’s fault that his version of Robert Mohr was Mr. Nice Guy. That’s on Breinersdorfer.
By the time we reluctantly left that conference in 2007, I had decided that when I convince Steve Molaro to make my White Rose miniseries, Alexander Held would reprise his role as Robert Mohr. But done right.
And now he can’t.
We will miss you, Alexander Held. You made this world a better place with your craft and kindness. Deepest sympathy to your family and real friends, the ones who kept you centered.
Postscript: When there’s stupid war carried out by stupid people, yes, then there’s senseless deaths. Senseless, senseless deaths. Putin’s invasion of Ukraine is on the shortlist with Hitler’s invasion of Poland for sheer stupidity.
Selfishly, I also mourn the rupture between German, American, and Russian scholarship. Igor and Dilya’s students were doing good work. There’s a great deal of primary source materials, not just about Alexander Schmorell, but about others associated with White Rose, that’s still buried in Russian military archives.
I personally believe that Werner Scholl’s documents are there. Theory, and a guess, but ask me why I think so.—Also, the Human Face of War project that Igor and I had initialized is now on hold.
That 2007 conference broadened my White Rose horizons immensely. I really, really want to go back to Orenburg in 2027.
Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.
If you enjoyed this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!
© 2026 Denise Elaine Heap. Please contact us for permission to quote.
Image credit: Top photograph--Alexander Held in Orenburg, Russia, Spetember 2007. © 2007 Dr. Igor Khramov. Used by permission. Second photograph--In Kazakhstan! We crossed the bridge from Orenburg to Kazakhstan. That's the Ural River behind us. L-R, my mom, me, M. Kaufmann, and Alexander Held. Photo © 2007 Rustam Galimov. Used by permission.
Bottom photograph--My troublemaking buddies. Alexander Held in the middle. They were behaving because they're sitting next to the pastor of the Lutheran church in Orenburg. Photo © 2007 Denise Elaine Heap.
Please contact us for permission to use any of these photographs. If the first two, I will forward your request to Igor and Rustam.
The above information is fully footnoted in our White Rose histories. Please purchase them for access to that material! To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.
No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.
