False narratives of victimhood

I will be upfront with you. This essay, along with a similar one that goes into greater detail, has been sitting on my To-Do list for over two years. It’s a hard one to write.

It wasn’t a completely unfamiliar theme. When I translated letters between my great-grandfather Sachs and the Thieme (Lutheran) side of his family in postwar Germany, I heard it. That was in the 1970s, working through correspondence dated 1945-1948. “We didn’t know. Hitler put honey in our mouth!”

Although that whining—even if it came from distant cousins—bothered me, it was nothing compared to what I felt in the early 1990s when Goethe Institut sent out invitations to lectures on the subject of Germans as victims. Multiple lectures, all of them focusing on a single topic: We Germans suffered every bit as much as Jews, Roma and Sinti, Jehovah’s Witnesses, LGBTQIA+, and Socialists-Communists.

The shrill voices also showed up wherever I spoke about White Rose resistance, about German resistance during the Shoah in the late 1990s and early 2000s. These people, usually born around 1920, so the same age as White Rose students, would raise their hands and whine, But we didn’t knoooooow. I was torn between my upbringing where you don’t talk back to your elders (and these 75- and 80-year-olds qualified as elders), and asking security to escort them out. If you’ve ever faced this dilemma, you know it’s hard.

Note too that these weeping wailers were often doing their protesting at Yom Ha-Shoah or interfaith meetings with Jewish community groups. In other words, they were elevating their victimhood to the same level as that of the concentration camp survivors sitting next to them.

However, the Goethe Institut lectures took it to a whole other level. We didn’t knoooooow wasn’t enough. “We Germans suffered every bit as much as Jews…”

As I did with all Internet resources, I printed those lecture announcements and lecture transcripts out and saved them for future reference. I struggled, however, with the “we didn’t know” argument. When I wrote White Rose History, Volume I, Chapter 14, I initially gave the Scholl family the benefit of the doubt. Although I already knew about the ellipses and how to interpret them (thank you, Inge Jens!), I hesitated asking questions out loud.

Therefore when Armin Ziegler fact-checked Chapter 14, the first email I received from him stated, “You can prioritize the ‘aversion of eyes’ of the Scholl children properly only when you know that they were still the only Aryan family in that house located at Adolf-Hitler-Ring 131 – with three Jewish families. There’s always talk about a Jewish classmate of Sophie whose fate she [Sophie] bemoaned. At least that’s what they say. But there is not one word recorded about the fate of these three families!!! They saw them up close and in person [hautnah] every day!! At least Sophie, Werner, Elisabeth, and Inge. Why did you leave this out?”

We continued the “we didn’t know” discussion over many weeks. This was something that Ziegler had clearly thought about—a lot. He was sixteen at war’s end. On the younger side of those who lived through the horrors his fellow countrymen inflicted on the Other. Beginning with German Jews, and not ending there.

Like Eugen Grimminger, whose biography Ziegler had written, Ziegler was born and raised in Crailsheim, which was the nearest big city to Forchtenberg and Öhringen, the Scholls’ hometowns. He was aware of revisionist histories his fellow citizens were compiling, in which they portrayed themselves as always philo-Semitic, as always protecting “their Jews.” Ziegler knew, and made sure I knew, that those were lies.

He published a book about Crailsheim and its reputation as the first German city to sponsor a pogrom against its Jewish families (March 1933). About Robert Scholl’s best friend’s aggressive and early position in the NSDAP’s eugenics campaign—in Crailsheim-Öhringen. About the antisemitism that caused almost all Jewish Germans to leave Crailsheim early on.

And he shared his thoughts as he penned the first draft of the Crailsheim book, a document that he knew would mean he’d never be welcome in his hometown again.

There are two things of which I accuse the people in Crailsheim (and all of us): 1. They (We) ‘looked the other way’ when their (our) fellow citizens became JEWS and were treated as such. (And this something of which I accuse even all the Germans who only learned about the Holocaust after the war. And that was nearly everyone. There were not all that many co-conspirators.) 2. And that there are still too many people who talk about the things that were done to the Jews. These things were done – in this case – to citizens of Crailsheim.”

Please note that Ziegler was anything but a Holocaust revisionist! His comment about looking away, about not understanding that German Jews were German, spoke to the dehumanization that began gradually and accelerated rapidly.

And Ziegler continued to hold my feet to the fire. We Germans KNEW that Jews were excluded from public parks and schools. Or, we Germans KNEW that neighbors were disappearing, and not one person filed a missing person’s report. Or, after Kristallnacht, not one single one of us helped a Jewish family rebuild their home or their business. We kept silent.

Email after email, Don’t let us off easy. We may not have known details. But WE KNEW.

We can understand this better in the USA in 2026 than we could in 1999, since there are elements of our society that do not recognize the Americanness of our citizens with Mexican, Somalian, or Haitian ancestry. We look the other way when our fellow CITIZENS become “Mexicans” and are deported for no reason whatever.

Thanks to Armin Ziegler, I revised my histories that very draft.

But I did not include information in my writing about Goethe Institut’s “German as victims” theme. I will expand on this in a longer version of this essay. Wish me luck, as it will be hard to write.

A few years ago as it became clear that this Germans as victims legend had gone underground, but still colored much of German Holocaust scholarship, I put this post on my To-Do list. When a topic becomes important enough to schedule, I immediately pull up the sources I’ll need to write the article and save them along with the To-Do list.

Only—

The numerous, and I mean numerous, announcements and lecture transcripts were suddenly missing from the Internet. Removed from the English and German Web sites of the Goethe Institut. The topic was therefore postponed.

Recent events, both in Germany and in the USA, pushed it towards the top of my list. In the past, what passes for Holocaust scholarship in both countries had simply failed to properly define the NSDAP affiliation of major characters in White Rose resistance, and in Germany at large. These days, those same Nazis are being venerated as upstanding citizens of a proud country.

As noted, the Germans as victims legend has gone underground, but it still colors the country’s history.

I therefore searched archives. The rest follows mostly from 2003 and prior, now purged. I cobbled together adequate resources to put this post together.


Shortly after Ernestine Schlant’s Language of Silence appeared, wherein she outed Günter Grass as someone she suspected of having been more deeply involved with Nazism than he would admit, Grass published Im Krebsgang [Crabwalk]. If the topic of West German, postwar literature interests you, find a copy of Schlant’s little book in a used bookstore. For an academic treatise, it’s easy to read and highlights the gaps in that literature, gaps that often reveal far more than the words on the page.

And Grass was someone Schlant clearly mistrusted. Turns out she was right.

Grass’ apparent hypothesis in Crabwalk: If Germany cannot talk about how its people were “victimized” by Hitler, Germans would become neo-Nazis. It was necessary to talk about their own “suffering” to prevent the Holocaust from recurring in Germany.

Please don’t misunderstand. Schlant admired Grass’ ability as a storyteller. She even admired his willingness, as a German, to attempt to portray Jewish characters in his novels. However, she pointed out that in all of Grass’ public speeches about his hopes for Germany in the 1980s and 1990s, he never once mentioned German Jews. Schlant noted that for Grass, German Jews are merely “inhabitants of the past… foreign visitors.”

I could go down the Ernestine Schlant rabbit hole and make this entire post about her book. I’ll avoid that temptation, but not before giving you one more quote: Literature tells a truth that is not necessarily the truth that the writer thinks he or she is saying.

Schlant was not the only German or history professor to express qualms about the direction Goethe Institut and some German literature headed in the 1980s and beyond. Robert Holub, of The Ohio State University, sounded the alarm in an essay written in the early 2000s and included in Colloquia Germanica in 2015. From his abstract:

While some commentators noted a shift toward the foregrounding of Germans as victims after 1990, these views came under increasing criticism during the past decade. More recent observers have rightfully noted that the discourse of German victimization has been present and continuous in writings dealing with Vergangenheitsbewältigung. What changed, I argue, was the nature of victimization: prior to 1990 German victims were rarely juxtaposed to the most obvious victims of the Nazis: those who suffered and were murdered in the Holocaust, especially the Jews.

I appreciated Ohio State University’s obituary for their esteemed colleague in 2023, asserting that he “had a sharp eye for flawed logic.” That is a skill one absolutely needs to be a professor of German literature or history. Sadly, there are too few Bob Holubs. His Buckeye friends noted that in his early years at Berkeley, Holub was known for “advocating for the field to move in the direction of intellectually rigorous, ethically engaged cultural studies.” Is it too late? Asking for a friend.

How I wish I had known him, especially after understanding that he was a rare soul who wouldn’t tolerate revisionist history that sought to equate Germans who brought their own suffering upon themselves, with the victims of Nazism!

Every February, you’ll also see reams of posts and online essays about the tragedy of Dresden, how the Allies were not justified in ruining such a beautiful noble city. (This is part of what I mean by “it’s gone underground” and is a subtext now, not overtly stated.)

I’d never known how to respond to those critics. If Dresden truly had no military value, if Dresden really were as blameless as all that, why did Allied bombers attack it with such ferocity? This thesis has been supported by such notable novelists as Kurt Vonnegut, who was a POW in the Schlachthof POW camps in February 1945. Since publication of that novel, conventional wisdom has proclaimed that what “we” (the Allies) did was a war crime.

Fast forward to the end of 2019 when I found myself in Dresden for three months on a business assignment. I spent way too much money at a small indie bookstore near my temporary residence. One such extravagant purchase was Matthias Gretzschel’s book about that firestorm, narrated from the POV of a family that survived. It’s not a novel. Nonfiction, with ample photographs and statistics.

To my shock, Gretzschel supported the Allied air strikes! Someone in DC or London must’ve had much better intelligence briefings than Kurt Vonnegut. Dresden had indeed become a military hub. It had the only intact railroad lines connecting Germany to the war on the Eastern front in Jan/Feb 1945. Traffic moved in both directions through the city: Bringing ethnic Germans westward, and carrying Jews and other Others to be executed eastward, along with munitions and supplies for beleaguered frontline soldiers.

Gretzschel made it clear: The bombings saved the lives of hundreds of so-called half-Jews in Germany, especially in Dresden. The day after the bombings began, trains had been scheduled to take those German “half-Jews” and “protected Jews” who were married to Aryans to the camps in Poland to be murdered. Among them, Victor Klemperer. And that, despite the liberation of Auschwitz.

I wrote about Gretzschel’s narrative here. It’s hard to feel sorry for the citizens of Dresden after reading his account. Am I happy that such a beautiful city was flattened? Of course not. Am I glad that 25,000+ people died in the firestorm? Absolutely not!

But I am glad that those remaining Jews who were headed to their deaths were spared. I am glad that supplies, food, and munitions did not head eastward on trains from Dresden. I am glad that “Dresden” placed a gigantic exclamation mark on a city that had been spared because it was not military, but that had allowed itself to be transformed into yet another military hub for the Nazis.

I warned you! This is hard!

To summarize what I have written—perhaps imperfectly—today:

  • “Germans as victims” fails on its most basic premise, because Germans were aware of the noose that tightened around the necks of Jewish (and Jehovah’s Witness, and LGBTQIA+, and socialist, and communist, and Roma/Sinti) neighbors. (Armin Ziegler)
  • Often, German guilt or shame can be found in the gaps, the unspoken truths, the failure to address critical elements of Germany’s systematic murder of people deemed undesirable. The vision of a future Germany, but still without Jews or Others. (Ernestine Schlant)
  • Equating Jews and others murdered by Nazis to themselves—Germans—as “victims” demonstrates flawed logic on the part of contemporary German society. (Robert Holub)
  • Sympathetic versions of cities—with Dresden as concrete example—and their populace coming under sustained Allied attack is misplaced sympathy, indicative of lack of knowledge of what was happening on the ground. (Matthias Gretzschel)
  • From all of the above: Inner emigration is a crock. Me!

All of which leads back to those lectures hosted by Goethe Institut, promoting the notion that German citizens were equally victimized by the Nazi regime, same as Jews, Poles, Roma, Sinti, Jehovah’s Witness, Socialists, Communists, and dissidents.

The longer post, the one I most dread writing, will pick up here and discuss the error of the concepts of inner emigration and Resistenz, as well as more about the role of the US government, the German government, the Deutsche Akademie, Goethe Institut, and Institut für Zeitgeschichte in perpetrating and perpetuating mythologies related to resistance during the Shoah, and the Holocaust in general.

I am buying a bulletproof vest between now and then!


For further reading:

  • Gretzschel, Matthias. Als Dresden im Feuersturm versank. Hamburg: Ellert & Richter Verlag, 2006.
  • Holub, Robert C. “Germans as Victims in 1995.” In Colloquia Germanica, Vol. 48, No. 1/2, 2015, pp. 23-33.
  • Popper, Nathaniel. “Germans Reexamine Their Own WWII Suffering.” The Forward. October 3, 2003.
  • Schlant, Ernestine. The Language of Silence: West German Literature and the Holocaust. New York: Routledge, 1999. I talked about Ernestine Schlant’s rejection of the notion of inner emigration here. She also came down hard on a White Rose favorite, Werner Bergengruen.
  • Schlant-Bradley, Ernestine. The Language of Silence. C-Span video from Temple Emanuel, Los Angeles. February 25, 2000. I heard her speak two months prior in Philadelphia. If you have any interest whatever in this topic, I highly recommend this 40-minute video “lecture.”
  • Ziegler, Armin. Crailsheim 1944 – Eine Stadt im totalen Krieg. Schönaich: Dr. Armin Ziegler, 2002.
  • Ziegler, Armin. Geschwister Scholl – Legenden, Fakten, offene Fragen. Schönaich: Dr. Armin Ziegler, 2001.

Questions? Comments? Speak your mind below. Before doing so, please log in using the email address that corresponds to your orders or newsletter subscription. Note: MARKDOWN is the app's label for formatting shortcuts.

If you learned something from this post and would like to leave me a tip, I would be grateful! Buy Me A Coffee!

© 2026 Denise Elaine Heap. Please contact us for permission to quote.

Image credits: Shopify, public domain for platform users.

To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume I: Coming Together (January 1933-April 30, 1942), click here. To order digital version of White Rose History, Volume II, click here. WRH1 is © 2002, 2003, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap. WRH2 is © 2002, 2007 by Denise Elaine Heap.

No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be reproduced in any form or by any electronic or mechanical means, including information storage and retrieval systems, without written permission from the copyright holder, except for the “fair use” of quotations that are properly cited and credited, including identification of the translator if applicable. No part of this post, Web site, or translations contained herein may be included in any Large Language Model without proper licensing from the copyright holder, Denise Elaine Heap.